Discussion about this post

User's avatar
HUMDEEDEE's avatar

Ahhh, it seems impossible to escape detection, the ever present devices gleaning what they can, all of it in my case mundane, of no importance to anyone, not even to me most of the time, but that doesn't mean it's not bad. I cover the cameras on my computer and iPad. God, I hate these devices more and more everyday but cannot find the will to do without them. How else would I know about Mark Bisone? I refuse to have a Ring or an Alexa or any other extraneous spy beyond the 3 I allow in my space. Good God! My devices have my digital fingerprint, but honestly, I can't summon the energy or interest to protect myself. One could never rest. Is this how it will end?

Expand full comment
Dr. Peter and Ginger Breggin's avatar

Sometimes I have the good fortune to select a link in an essay, and stumble upon another essay so descriptive of the encroaching future that it leaves me a little stunned and brimming with resonance of my own previously unremarked experiences. I remember I had a Chatty Cathy doll as a child, and so I found myself getting my young daughter a Teddy Ruxton toy in the 1980s that survived until the late 90s when a flying squirrel invasion in our attic crawl space left a layer of dreck so deep I had to call in a white suited clean up company looking a great deal like the virus hunters we are now familiar with, to clean up the mess.

And your reminder of the talking crosswalk signs! There is one, downtown, right next to the hotel we stayed in the first weekend we visited Ithaca in 2002. All night it would be triggered...wait...wait...wait...and we could hear it on the 6th floor of the hotel....

Reading this beautiful essay, I am aware of our good fortune that we don't live in a thoroughly modern city....and how I instinctively avoid all the droning mechanical voices coming at me from self-checkout lines in restaurants and grocery stores. And I am grateful that I have avoided getting "Alexa" or any other digital "helpers". But I cannot avoid the smart phone in my left hip pocket all day, and our computer....

How do we start to re-humanize ourselves? As you said so poignantly, Mark "reminding us that weโ€™re not just countrymen and neighbors, but children of God and potential friends."

Your essay gives me a great foreboding: that we have lost our cities, our technologically ensnared hubs and that we must resist all the attempts at technology being introduced into our smaller living communities. Yes, resist "15 minute cities" but further than that--resist any technologies that dehumanize the daily experience. If we fail to do so, our Ubers, our taxi, our own cars, will be mechanizes and "self driven" by technology. And our daily outings that used to be a quick way to encounter other humans will only encounter machines and the great, unknowable technocrats running our lives.

Ginger Breggin

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts